Chapter 1

"Senpai, you're kinda..." (センパイってちょっと…) is the first chapter of the Don't Toy With Me, Miss Nagatoro manga series.

Summary
After the end of classes, a second year high schooler walked into the library expecting to find it empty as usual, only to discover a group of four girls actually went there to chat. Being timid and introverted, the boy sat quietly a few tables afar from them trying to finish his homework, however due to having let his schoolbag open, the pages of the manga he started to drew the previous night fall to the floor and are immediately spotted by the girls who started to mercilessly criticize it and making fun on him, until one of them got a text from a friend who invited them all at a bakery called Mister Donuts, prompting three of them to go.

The remained girl introduced herself as a first year student and guessed he is an year her senior and, then, her "Senpai". The girl then started to read the manga out loud: the story of Siegfried, a skilled swordsman who's bad at getting on in the world, who met and became ally with a beautiful knight of an enemy country, Elizabeth, and they fell in love. Seeing that the character has a graphical resemblance with him, the girl asked Senpai if he projected himself on the character and then called both "pitiful".

The girl especially pointed out a scene in the manga in which, after the female lead stated that she has long abandoned being a woman, the protagonist caressed her hair calling her beautiful and thus making her blush. She proposed to reenact the scene and, after showing her martial arts skills and repeating Elizabeth's exact line, she invited him to play Siegfried's part, however he was too shy to touch her hair, prompting the girl to said that that's how the scene should have been made, as only confident men could do that while a virgin-looking character like him wouldn't. The girl called Senpai's character "flat" making him cry a little thus, he tried to avoid eye contact in order not to made her notice he was crying, however she put him with his back to the wall and called him "gross" eventually reducing him to tears.

She then gently wiped his tears away with her handkerchief and, after cheerfully apologizing for having bullied him, get away leaving him mumble alone on how a kōhai made him cry.

Characters

 * Hayase Nagatoro
 * Senpai
 * Gamo-chan (unnamed)
 * Yoshi (unnamed)
 * Sakura (unnamed)

Trivia

 * As of this chapter the two main characters met each others but had yet to introduce to one another.
 * In the following two chapters Senpai only referred to Nagatoro as "that girl" or "kōhai" (meaning "junior", the opposite of "senpai").
 * When Nagatoro's friends (all unnamed and partially unseen in this chapter) commented Senpai's manga the only two with spoken lines are Gamo-chan and Yoshi, however only the first criticized it, while the latter actually complimented it stating it was "Cool" and "Better than One Piece", only at that point Sakura intervenes saying simply that Yoshi's statement was a little too much.
 * Also, when Gamo-chan said that a friend of theirs, Yuko, was at Mister Donuts and proposed to go there, Sakura responded that she has to go to her shift, implying that she has some sort of part-time job.
 * Despite all of Nagatoro's friend are partially shadowed in this chapter, each of the three are quite recognizable for their trademark attire and hairs, except for Sakura who has significantly longer hair.